This puzzle connects with the idea of different bases, as the two-pan scale connects to the base-3 system, given that we have 3 choices of where the weight can be placed (on the pan with the herb, without the herb, or not on the scale at all). Since base 3 then uses values which connect to the powers of 3, we see that we have weights that are equal to 1, 3, 9, and 27 aka 3^0, 3^1, 3^2, and 3^3, where within base 3, all numbers from 1 to 40 can thus be written as some linear combination of these values. Since the one-pan scale only gives us two options of placement for the weight (on or off of the scale), we instead use the base-2 system to hit every value from 1 to 31 using linear combinations of the values 1, 2, 4, 8, 16, which corresponds to 2 to the powers 0 through 4.
To extend this puzzle, one could modify it to allow for 2 weights of the same size on the one-pan scale and see how this then works/forces a base-3 system. For example, seeing that to get a value like 20, you'd use two 9g weights and two 1g weights, whereas once you upgrade to two-pan scale you can get the original setup where you have 4 completely different weights only.
Your idea of allowing repeated weights creates an interesting extension of the puzzle. I wonder how you would explain this change to students so they could understand why using two of each weight connects to base 3. It also makes me think about how important it is for us as teachers to make our mathematical reasoning clear, not just arrive at the correct answer.
ReplyDelete