One section of the article that gave me pause while reading was the discussion on common/recurring perceptions of numbers by the general population, instead of only those with synesthesia. I found the study results cited in this section quite interesting, as I found myself agreeing with many of the perceptions that the public had, such as finding even numbers more calm, disliking numbers ending in 3, 7, and 9, and finding values like 8 more solid and less obtrusive than 9. I find that personally this may be, in part, due to the other connotations/usage of the terms odd and even that we have in society. For example, ‘even,’ outside of the number sense, can refer to being balanced or fair, thus helping the connection between even numbers and being solid or balanced. ‘Odd,’ outside of the number sense, can refer to a person or thing that is strange or out of the ordinary, thus forming the connection between odd numbers and being obtrusive or deadly or excitable. I assume then that those with a first language other than English could easily have different associations and perceptions of the numbers, if the words they use to mean even and odd numbers do not have these alternate meanings that could cause such connections to take root.
Another point at which I paused was during the author’s discussion of numbers’ relation to her own creative pursuit of poetry. I can relate this to my own connection between numbers and music, given that I play an instrument, and the connection between numbers like 4 and 8 as being balanced and even because they are common amounts/measures for tempo or beats. Again, I think this illustrates why we have certain perceptions of numbers, as this connection I have between even numbers and being balanced due to the English meaning of ‘even’ is only further reinforced by the ways in which I experience and use even numbers in music to keep myself “balanced” and on tempo, thereby further associating even numbers with positive ideas of being balanced, solid, stable, and so on.
Kia's EDCP 442 Blog
Monday, November 16, 2026
Monday, October 19, 2026
Egyptian Wall Painting - Questions/Thoughts
Possible mathematical activities being carried out:
- Measurement of some sort, as seen by those unspooling a rope/string and pulling taut into a line
- Possible weighing of items, seen by those holding out two different items in hand, akin to a scale
- Perhaps counting methods, visualized in the lower half by one figure who has multiple arms/hands and is drawing something onto them
- Some element of writing out or drawing out math, from the figures kneeling with writing tools and paper-like materials
Questions about what is depicted:
- How connected are the various figures and activities meant to be?
- Are they depicting one particular story/recount or is it a collection of routine/daily activities at this time?
- What is symbolized by having the different heights and positions of the figures (are the smaller ones children? does the hunching/kneeling signify a class or role in society?)
- Is there meaning behind the upper portion seemingly being outside/having a farm/agriculture visual aspect compared to the lower portion visually appearing to be inside? Does it represent the sorts of math application in real world (measuring, weighing etc) versus what we do more abstractly (counting, writing, scribing math)?
After reading the article, one thing I found interesting and somewhat surprising was the Ancient Egyptians unit of length being derived from the length from the elbow to the tip of the middle finger. While I suppose I was technically aware prior to reading that many units of measurement originally began from body parts or physical items etc., I think I am still intrigued by the choice of the arm compared to say the foot and the practical applications of a unit of measurement that can technically differ by person. One question that came to me directly from this point is: what other math units or even whole concepts are originally derived from humans' awareness and use of their physical form?
On the point raised in the article of surveying being used by the Ancient Egyptians for the purpose of constructing tombs and temples, I also wonder how many math concepts and understandings were born out of ideological, theological purposes, rather than survival-based utility applications? Without getting too philosophical, can these purposes in fact be considered applications needed for survival given the uniting role of ideas and theologies in societies, and is it possible to identify any math concept that has been derived and discussed that was not originally raised because of human motivations?
Ancient/Modern Methods - Individual Reflection
As I reflect on the Ancient vs. Modern Methods project, a few useful insights do appear that could be useful for my future practice. In particular, our group, and notably many others, chose to begin with the ancient proof during our presentation and then extend to the modern methods, which may be quicker/more effective but are conceptually more abstract or complicated. I feel this speaks to the conceptual simplicity of ancient methods, because of the mathematical constraints that ancient peoples were still working within. In particular, these methods, which are often visual, geometrical, or use strategies of rearrangement, counting, etc., provide a stronger conceptual understanding of both the objective of the problem, as well as the solution and underlying theorem or formulas. I feel that incorporating more of these ancient conceptualizations of math problems and solutions in real math classrooms could not only provide historical and cultural value, but also help students grasp the math on a conceptual level before jumping to a formulaic understanding. Immediately using modern methods may contribute to students’ sense of disconnect between abstract math and the real world, and reinforce bad math habits of memorizing formulas and requiring every problem to look the same to seem solvable.
Such exercises in the math classroom may also help students see the full scope of available strategies to solve any one math problem. This may help cement the idea that math, which is often mischaracterized as having one correct answer and thus one correct solution path, is actually carried out through a myriad of methods, empowering students to feel they have the ability to select routes of conceptualizing and doing math in ways that make sense to them. While at times the curriculum will force us as teachers to check for their understanding and ability to use certain specific solution routes, I hope to incorporate as many opportunities as possible for students to explore and learn math in ways that suit them.
Monday, October 5, 2026
Monday, September 28, 2026
Babylonian word problems - response
Within the chapter, I paused at the mention of how many math workbooks today aim to provide “real word” examples, yet include ones that are so contrived that they actually become meaningless for the student. This makes me think of many examples I encountered in my own time in grade school where the class would laugh at some word problem that consists of an individual buying a few hundred watermelons and the like. While it was clear what concept these word problems were trying to get at, they were not necessarily achieving the goal of showing us the use of math in real life, unless you could look beyond the numbers and see the broader concept, such as something like "math may be used in calculating costs." However, it was interesting to see that perhaps word problems were still very contrived even at the time when the Babylonians were doing math. These word problems seem to have the same goal of aiming for the concept of using math to calculate things like area and such, but, just as in the modern day, may be forced to use strange values and situations for the sake of learning that does not necessarily keep them realistic.
I also found interesting the suggestion that this may point to there being no clear divide between pure and applied mathematics, and that we may need to question whether any true “real-life” problems exist or if all must contain certain features that make situations perfect and unrealistic compared to real situations, such that math can be applied easily for student learning. While requiring a bit of a stretch, this point made me wonder about how we attempt to separate math classes into streams at the secondary level. In particular, these courses are often separated as some being more “real-world” or applied, and thus better for students who plan to immediately enter the “real world” post-secondary. If it appears that we struggle to actually teach something real about the world through our word problems, I just wonder how well we are connecting course content in such foundations or apprenticeship style math classes or the curriculum at large to concepts or problems they may genuinely encounter in life. In particular, it makes me wonder how truly beneficial these math classes are for these students and also if there truly is any clear line to be drawn between the streams that focus more on abstract/pure math vs applied.
In general, I also noticed that most of the problems likely struggle with this true real-world connection because they are being written to be solvable by the students so that they can learn the math tools, and the chapter includes the point that it thus may not be out of any inherent interest in the topic being connected. I do think this may suggest there is a time and place for the more contrived word problems that are being used out of pure utility to help students pick up on the math concepts, and a time when we should encourage students to do projects or research into genuine real-world applications of math, to gain some personal insight on how math is played out or applied in some area of their interest.
One other concern I have with the more contrived word-problems in students' workbooks today is the kind of habits it might be causing. Namely, we often urge students to read word problems more carefully and to identify all important pieces of information and their relationship to each other before beginning their solution, to ensure minimal errors. However, the more contrived the values or situations get, while still using the same general format, it makes me wonder if this only further encourages students to skip over many of the words or supposed “real-world” situation of the problem and jump right into applying the formula to the numbers. I think this particularly happens if they encounter a lot of the exact same format of word problem, just with some new crazy scenario and new values, and so they come to disregard the words and race to apply the formulas instead, possibly causing them to miss important information when the word problem format actually does change. Perhaps if each word-problem was produced with more care and to be more realistic and more unique from others, students would be less likely to develop this habit of jumping over the provided information, necessary for solving the problem.
I also found interesting the suggestion that this may point to there being no clear divide between pure and applied mathematics, and that we may need to question whether any true “real-life” problems exist or if all must contain certain features that make situations perfect and unrealistic compared to real situations, such that math can be applied easily for student learning. While requiring a bit of a stretch, this point made me wonder about how we attempt to separate math classes into streams at the secondary level. In particular, these courses are often separated as some being more “real-world” or applied, and thus better for students who plan to immediately enter the “real world” post-secondary. If it appears that we struggle to actually teach something real about the world through our word problems, I just wonder how well we are connecting course content in such foundations or apprenticeship style math classes or the curriculum at large to concepts or problems they may genuinely encounter in life. In particular, it makes me wonder how truly beneficial these math classes are for these students and also if there truly is any clear line to be drawn between the streams that focus more on abstract/pure math vs applied.
In general, I also noticed that most of the problems likely struggle with this true real-world connection because they are being written to be solvable by the students so that they can learn the math tools, and the chapter includes the point that it thus may not be out of any inherent interest in the topic being connected. I do think this may suggest there is a time and place for the more contrived word problems that are being used out of pure utility to help students pick up on the math concepts, and a time when we should encourage students to do projects or research into genuine real-world applications of math, to gain some personal insight on how math is played out or applied in some area of their interest.
One other concern I have with the more contrived word-problems in students' workbooks today is the kind of habits it might be causing. Namely, we often urge students to read word problems more carefully and to identify all important pieces of information and their relationship to each other before beginning their solution, to ensure minimal errors. However, the more contrived the values or situations get, while still using the same general format, it makes me wonder if this only further encourages students to skip over many of the words or supposed “real-world” situation of the problem and jump right into applying the formula to the numbers. I think this particularly happens if they encounter a lot of the exact same format of word problem, just with some new crazy scenario and new values, and so they come to disregard the words and race to apply the formulas instead, possibly causing them to miss important information when the word problem format actually does change. Perhaps if each word-problem was produced with more care and to be more realistic and more unique from others, students would be less likely to develop this habit of jumping over the provided information, necessary for solving the problem.
Market Scales Puzzle
This puzzle connects with the idea of different bases, as the two-pan scale connects to the base-3 system, given that we have 3 choices of where the weight can be placed (on the pan with the herb, without the herb, or not on the scale at all). Since base 3 then uses values which connect to the powers of 3, we see that we have weights that are equal to 1, 3, 9, and 27 aka 3^0, 3^1, 3^2, and 3^3, where within base 3, all numbers from 1 to 40 can thus be written as some linear combination of these values. Since the one-pan scale only gives us two options of placement for the weight (on or off of the scale), we instead use the base-2 system to hit every value from 1 to 31 using linear combinations of the values 1, 2, 4, 8, 16, which corresponds to 2 to the powers 0 through 4.
To extend this puzzle, one could modify it to allow for 2 weights of the same size on the one-pan scale and see how this then works/forces a base-3 system. For example, seeing that to get a value like 20, you'd use two 9g weights and two 1g weights, whereas once you upgrade to two-pan scale you can get the original setup where you have 4 completely different weights only.
Wednesday, September 23, 2026
Babylonian Algebra and Mesopotamian Scribes - Thoughts
Before the development of notation, it is clear that math was still being done rhetorically, in the fashion of Babylonian algebra using words such as breadth and length to explicitly write out what we now abbreviate to symbols like ‘l’ and ‘w.’ When I think about how this can apply to more principle generalizations, I feel this may actually ease the transition from the specific to the general, since the principles of math themselves are often written in words to describe the key concept. For example, we may know the formula for the area of a rectangle using the symbolic shorthand for the sake of utility, but in stating a general principle on how we ought to view the area of a rectangle and how we can find it, we would certainly state this in terms of things like the rectangle's width and length and their relationship, rather than saying the rectangle's "l and w."
This could tie into how students learn in our classrooms today, since we may now see why it is actually rather ineffective or confusing for students to first introduce this short hand or symbolic methods of algebra and expect them to conclude from here the general principles which are free of the symbols and instead speak to the greater concepts and relationships that actually drive why things work. Perhaps this should inform how we teach, in that students likely could develop firmer/deeper understandings of math, rather than just the ability to apply memorized symbolic formulas, if we moved them from rhetoric, to syncopated, and only lastly on to symbolic. This way, they learn algebra in plain words which they already know, then begin minor substituting or mixing of words and symbols, until they are fully comfortable moving to symbols entirely, as it is now simply a representative shorthand for a broader idea they have already learnt.
This could tie into how students learn in our classrooms today, since we may now see why it is actually rather ineffective or confusing for students to first introduce this short hand or symbolic methods of algebra and expect them to conclude from here the general principles which are free of the symbols and instead speak to the greater concepts and relationships that actually drive why things work. Perhaps this should inform how we teach, in that students likely could develop firmer/deeper understandings of math, rather than just the ability to apply memorized symbolic formulas, if we moved them from rhetoric, to syncopated, and only lastly on to symbolic. This way, they learn algebra in plain words which they already know, then begin minor substituting or mixing of words and symbols, until they are fully comfortable moving to symbols entirely, as it is now simply a representative shorthand for a broader idea they have already learnt.
I find this also speaks to why mathematics is not all about generalization and abstraction, even if these categories help to cover or sum up much of the broad concepts of math. Generalizations and abstractions often have the key benefit of being highly transferable within the broad topic and they help us make connections between different areas as well. However, mathematical application is an important part of math that lies in clear contrast to abstraction. Additionally, highly specific proofs can be very important for understanding or 'proving' areas of math, even though they are far from being general or transferable topics. For other areas of mathematical knowledge, like geometry and number theory, I therefore think it is still possible to state general or abstract relationships without algebra, as we can see that even many proofs in these topics are already done only in words, drawings, and ideas, rather than symbols and algebra. For example, many geometry proofs and principles can be discussed without algebra, in that we can construct the ideas instead with basic methods of compass and straight edge.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
Numbers with Personality - Thoughts on Alice Major's article
One section of the article that gave me pause while reading was the discussion on common/recurring perceptions of numbers by the general pop...
-
Before reading the article, my general perspective is that math history should be incorporated into teaching, as I feel it provides students...
-
Before the development of notation, it is clear that math was still being done rhetorically, in the fashion of Babylonian algebra using word...
-
Within the chapter, I paused at the mention of how many math workbooks today aim to provide “real word” examples, yet include ones that are ...