Monday, October 19, 2026
Ancient/Modern Methods - Individual Reflection
As I reflect on the Ancient vs. Modern Methods project, a few useful insights do appear that could be useful for my future practice. In particular, our group, and notably many others, chose to begin with the ancient proof during our presentation and then extend to the modern methods, which may be quicker/more effective but are conceptually more abstract or complicated. I feel this speaks to the conceptual simplicity of ancient methods, because of the mathematical constraints that ancient peoples were still working within. In particular, these methods, which are often visual, geometrical, or use strategies of rearrangement, counting, etc., provide a stronger conceptual understanding of both the objective of the problem, as well as the solution and underlying theorem or formulas. I feel that incorporating more of these ancient conceptualizations of math problems and solutions in real math classrooms could not only provide historical and cultural value, but also help students grasp the math on a conceptual level before jumping to a formulaic understanding. Immediately using modern methods may contribute to students’ sense of disconnect between abstract math and the real world, and reinforce bad math habits of memorizing formulas and requiring every problem to look the same to seem solvable.
Such exercises in the math classroom may also help students see the full scope of available strategies to solve any one math problem. This may help cement the idea that math, which is often mischaracterized as having one correct answer and thus one correct solution path, is actually carried out through a myriad of methods, empowering students to feel they have the ability to select routes of conceptualizing and doing math in ways that make sense to them. While at times the curriculum will force us as teachers to check for their understanding and ability to use certain specific solution routes, I hope to incorporate as many opportunities as possible for students to explore and learn math in ways that suit them.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
Numbers with Personality - Thoughts on Alice Major's article
One section of the article that gave me pause while reading was the discussion on common/recurring perceptions of numbers by the general pop...
-
Before reading the article, my general perspective is that math history should be incorporated into teaching, as I feel it provides students...
-
Before the development of notation, it is clear that math was still being done rhetorically, in the fashion of Babylonian algebra using word...
-
Within the chapter, I paused at the mention of how many math workbooks today aim to provide “real word” examples, yet include ones that are ...
No comments:
Post a Comment